model roles?

Jason Gardner's avatar
Posted by Jason Gardner Fri, 17/06/2005 - 10:28am :: People | more by Jason Gardner

The popularity of our role models can be a useful measure of the values and priorities of our society.

So, what does it say when our young people no longer aspire to become skilled craftsmen or pioneering artists but instead choose to emulate ‘personalities’ such as Abi Titmuss, Jordan and Jodie Marsh?

According to a recent survey among 15-19-year-old girls by the ‘interactive entertainment website’ www.thelab.tv, 63 per cent now wish to become ‘glamour models’ instead of doctors, teachers or nurses.

When asked what they’d like to be known for, 89 per cent said they’d like to be recognised as a celebrity, as opposed to a mere 11 per cent who sought ‘achievement with little recognition’.

It’s not surprising, in a world saturated with ‘glamorous’ images of young women, that teenagers associate success and acceptance with having a figure that’s been enhanced by a surgeon or computer.

It’s surely, too, a symptom of our get-rich-and-famous-quick culture – as celebrated by the National Lottery and Big Brother - that teenagers believe that baring all is the most painless route to stardom and wealth (apart, that is, from the plastic surgeon’s scalpel…).

That’s certainly been true for Abi Titmuss, who became famous simply for being John Leslie’s girlfriend, before then re-marketing herself and appearing 68 times (and counting) on the front of national newspapers. Her ‘modelling’ ‘career’ has so far gained her over a million pounds, though she agreed with one newspaper which called her ‘the most pointless celebrity around’.

Can we hope to counter such a shallow aspirational culture, and point young people towards a more positive future? Significantly, the American psychologist Amy Taublieb suggests that ‘if a young person has emotional/psychological security as well as open lines of communication with parents, the actual influence (of media) is minimal.’

Love, in the form of active and involved mentoring, is the key; a formula that Moses saw as essential to the flourishing of the Israelite nation. After issuing the commandment to ‘love the lord your God with all your heart, soul and strength’ he implored them to ‘impress these laws on your children’ (Deuteronomy 6).

If, as Christians, we also hope that our young people will choose Christ as their ultimate role model, then our lifelong passion must be to model effectively the way of Jesus, too.

Jason Gardner

additional resources

Some useful resources on role models are parked at www.theory.org.uk.

What do you want to be when you grow up? For a bit more help, visit www.womenswork.org/girls.

Another role model project for girls can be found at www.rolemodel.net.

'Making Devoted Disciples: How to be an effective mentor' by Erik Johnson in www.christinaitytoday.com.

'Is Abi Titmuss a sign of the times? I'm afraid she probably is' by Jim White at www.telegraph.co.uk.

'Naked ambition rubs off on teenage girls' in the Manchester News Online, at www.manchesteronline.co.uk.

For more info on Amy Tautlieb, visit www.iparenting.com.

I think we have so distorted
Posted by  Anonymous on Fri, 17/06/2005 - 12:29pm.
I think we have so distorted the picture of what the Lord is like that it is very difficult for the young people to want to model their lives on Him.
Is it fair to single-out
Posted by  Anonymous on Fri, 17/06/2005 - 2:13pm.
Is it fair to single-out these three human-beings in order to make your point? It might make your article an interesting read to those who know who these people are, but I wonder how much respect they might have for your points-of-view, and indeed the moral of your story. Everyone follows a different path in life and in many cases not by their own choice (even though you might think they do). I don't believe you should make a bad example of people you really know nothing about.
Re: is it fair to single out.
Posted by  Jason Gardner on Tue, 21/06/2005 - 12:34pm.
I would hope that if the celebrities mentioned did come across this article that they'd be challenged to become more positive role models. And in a country that has the highest STI rates and Teen pregnancies in europe I find it difficult to see how you can make a good example out of people who make a living through selling themselves as sex idols.
Missing the point?
Posted by  Rob G on Wed, 22/06/2005 - 12:18pm.
The article is talking about how the world perceives these role models. Whether they are really like this or not is actually irrelevent; the point is we do know what they are famous for and what people look up to in them. The author is not judging these three people, he is pointing out the fact that people look up to them for bad reasons.
model roles?
Posted by  SHeavenor on Sat, 18/06/2005 - 12:13am.
I don't think we have been taught to love the Lord our God with all of our heart, soul and strength. In many Christian circles the heart, soul,and strength would be seen as being of the "flesh" . So what kind of role model does this produce? It's no wonder that young people are uninspired by Christianity and their view of the Lord is distorted.
I question the validity of the survey
Posted by  Anonymous on Fri, 24/06/2005 - 3:49am.
I question the validity of the survey. I wonder what girls are responding to a questionaire put out by an'interactive entertainment website'. I would agree that there are too many young women who believe that the only value they have is in their body/looks.I would agree that the media has posited this idea. My question now would be 'who else supports this misconception'?
I believe men have as much responsibility to speak out and disclaim the rubbish put forth in all forms on media (including print) as the young girls it is aimed towards. Father's teaching their boys to respect women (all women) would be a great start.Stating that parents are responsible to develop in their children the knowledge of God's perfect love for them and the appropriate response to the culture around us should go without saying.
Taking a stand on these issues is difficult in today's climate. Taking a stand as a 12/15 year old impossible unless parents and clergy are willing to take the UNCOMFORTABLE place in our society as Jesus intended. As long as mothers think owning more 'stuff' and relying on plastic surgery or endless hours in the gym is spending her time, money and talents as God intended and as long as fathers spend more time at work than at home and believe they are what they do and value one another according to the cars they drive, where they live or what club they belong to; we will be a far cry from the people Jesus called us to be. I wonder what we might see in the eyes of Jesus if he returned now and saw what we had done with his gift.
As parents we need to 'humble' ourselves before our God and also before our kids.Let them know of the mistakes we have made, of the lessons we have learned and stop thinking we stand perfect before them (they are much smarter than that and already know our mistakes). Then we need to CHANGE our behaviour and 'put our money where our mouth is' and ACT as we know we are called to act.Letting our kids know that the journey here is our 'training' ground where God will teach us much IF we are willing to accept all he has to offer us would be a major step. It would involve acknowledging that HERE isn't what it is all about. What a fresh perspective, especially when done with love and patience and not anger, judgement or ridicule. With a true understanding of how difficult it is for today's youth.....and how ALL things are possible with GOD.
This mom from the states has seen it work...and the joy you will get from raising up godly youth who truely value themselves as children of the King is more reward than you could possibly ask for.It isn't pain free. Disappointment and discouragement has been experienced along with failures and successes. Our God is a Mighty God....but he does require participation.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click 'Save settings' to activate your changes.

With love (and extra resources, group-work ideas and links...)
from
www.licc.org.uk/culture.