roots to happiness

Brian Draper's avatar
Posted by Brian Draper Fri, 19/01/2007 - 1:00am :: Books and Literature | People | more by Brian Draper

Recently, I’ve been wondering: Does my ‘community’ work for me any more? I’ve been part of a little gathering of Christian searchers, church refugees, dreamers and mavericks for several years now, but it’s hardly a model of church growth to rival Mars Hill…

We share our beliefs with each other, yet we don’t always know what to do with them. As we’re experimental, it doesn’t seem appropriate to pin our colours to a mast, let alone to commit to a way, a path, a rhythm… And as I’m forever wondering privately if I and my family might move on, it’s hard to feel settled.

This week, I visited a place I mistakenly still call ‘home’. I spent all my growing years in the same small country town I was born in. I could walk to school – no 4x4 jams - and the same faces accompanied me the length of the educational journey. Although there was little to do in the town once the cinema was bulldozed, you felt a part of things, ironically, because you had no choice: you were going nowhere in a hurry. You knew, and were known by, everyone.

In an intriguing new book on community, Utopian Dreams, Tobias Jones laments the ‘uprootedness’ of life today, the worship of choice and the lack of a sense of the sacred in society. As an experiment, he lived with several ‘intentional communities’, most of which are spiritual, the best of which, he believes, are Christian.

Afterwards, enriched by the experience, he decided to stop travelling and put down some roots. He drew a circle two miles across on a map, with his house at the centre, and resolved to find community within it. Commitment to ‘place’ is like a marriage, he argues: by making a lasting decision, you dispense with choice, and gain the freedom to start living with those around you.

So, how long do you give a church, a place or a person before you give up on them? If my community doesn’t work for me, perhaps I should start working, instead, for my community. We can resist being tied down for as long as we choose, but life is short - it was the funeral of one of those schoolfriends that drew me ‘home’ this week - and I’m coming to realise that ultimately I don’t want my epitaph simply to say: ‘He kept his options open.’

Brian Draper

additional resources

Tobias Jones’s book Utopian Dreams: In Search of a Good Life was published this month by Faber and Faber.

Here is what the Observer, the Guardian and the Independent made of the book.

Among the communities Jones visited were the Danmanhur Community in Italy, which has its own underground temple and a ‘symbolic’ language of 300 carefully designed pictures, the Catholic community Nomadelfia and the Pilsdon Community in Dorset, a Christian community that helps people through depression, alcoholism, addiction, divorce and bereavement.

Brian Draper has interviewed Jones for Church Times. The article will appear next Friday, 26 January. For more info, visit churchtimes.co.uk.

If you have any stories about ‘intentional community’ life, please post them below. We’d love to hear of your experiences.

Hey Brian, Have just read yo
Posted by  Gwennie on Fri, 19/01/2007 - 4:07pm.
Hey Brian,
Have just read your piece on Roots to Happiness & feel like you've been eavesdropping inside my head!
Unlike you, I moved around a lot as a child, including a transatlantic move, & this trend carried on into my adult life, leaving me with a sense of not knowing where I belonged and an increasing longing to be part of a community. I thought I had found it within a church movement but was bitterly disappointed when a lot of their lofty aims turned out to be hot air.
So, stuck in London through circumstances rather than choice, I fumed & waited,keeping my options open, & longed for escape to the perfect living/job/friendship/church situation where I would, finally, belong, be happy, be fulfilled.
But, as the years have gone by, the truth of that saying - life is what happens while you're waiting for something else (or something like that)- has become apparent to me. My longing for community has been gradually fulfiled, without me even realising it at first, by just living in one place for a long time (which I'd never done before).
Through engaging with my local community, via school, work, even dog walking!, I've slowly become a part of the place & made aquaintances and friends. My kids have grown up here & don't want to escape with me to anywhere else! This is their home.
The only thing missing has been a church community. We felt very strongly that we should have our faith community within the community in which we lived but, having visited many churches, couldn't find one where we felt at home.
Gradually, I think as I felt more at home in my locality, we decided to visit the one Christian group we had never been to - which just happened to be based up the road in our local Anglican church where the kids had gone for Christmas services with the school for years.
It also transpired that we had a passing aquaintance with some of the people there thro other community involvement. And at a recent Christmas gathering, my daughter ended up talking to a teacher from her school! For the first time in my life I am experiencing a true, unforced overlap of faith & living communities. An honest mix of "the sacred & the secular".
It's not all rosy in the garden tho. This faith group is unlike anything we've ever been involved with before. It is very similar to what you described in your faith community, Brian, and is involving a leap of faith to just stick with it, get to know people, contribute rather that criticise & see waht happens. It feels foreign but right at the same time, and, God is there and surely, that is more important than traditions.
Like you also, having been to 5 funerals in 2 years, I'm realising that life is short. Almost without realising it, I've become committed to this place which I now call home & am choosing to commit to a local faith community, rather than sit back & see what it can do for me. I guess this is a form of intentional community life - an experimental pushing of the boundaries of trying to bring the sacred into society - it just didn't happen the way I wanted it to!
credentials for staying with a church
Posted by  brett jordan on Sat, 20/01/2007 - 9:46pm.
John Calvin said in The Institutes of Christian Religion... ”The Lord esteems the communion of his Church so highly that he counts as traitor and apostate from Christianity anyone who arrogantly leaves any Christian society, provided it cherishes the true ministry of the Word and sacraments.”

good enough for me

brett
Hey Brett, What does good ol
Posted by  Gwennie on Wed, 24/01/2007 - 1:07am.
Hey Brett,
What does good old John say about circumstances where the Christian society arrogantly leaves you? High & dry? Without an apology let alone pastoral care?
I guess I'm still not over this experience since just the mere mention of John Calvin raises my hackles. I'm most likely not being fair to him but was soundly put off him & his Institutes by a Christian Doctrine lecturer I suffered under who seemed to esteem JC (John Calvin) more highly than the JC (Jesus Christ) I wanted to learn about.
I'm aware my tone is sarcastic - it's a protective mechanism - but I am making a serious point. "Refugees from the Church", as Brian puts it, don't need more guilt heaped on them by an old bloke from the past. They need REAL community where there exists love & compassion as well as the ministry of the word & true sacraments. Without the love, the rest is a clanging cymbal. I know cos I grew up in it.
I'm not trying to be argumentative - I would really like to hear what other people think.
Best,
Gwen
Calvin as pastor...
Posted by  brett jordan on Fri, 26/01/2007 - 8:44pm.
hi gwen

firstly, i'm really sorry to hear that christian society has left you high and dry... as someone who has gone through divorce, i can empathise with you

john calvin was a 'child of his time' (scholarly talk for 'an old bloke from the past' :-), but from what i have read about him, i think he was an extremely loving and caring guy

there are a number of translations of the institutes (battle and beveridge's being the most popular), and if you ever got the chance to study them, i think you would be surprised at how clear and 'uncalvinistic' he is... calvinism, a bit like golf, and christianity itself, is not always best appreciated by watching its followers!

there is an article about his pastoral side available online

http://department.monm.edu/classics/Speel_Festschrift/baumann.htm

which might be worth a browse... one extract from it shows that calvin was someone who cared deeply for people

"Here is one of countless illustrations that could be cited with regard to how Calvin cared for people: In 1538 when the reformer was in Basel, Switzerland he learned that the nephew of another French reformer, Guillaume Farel, had been stricken with the plague. Without fear of danger and thinking only of his responsibility, he went to the bedside of the sick boy in order to take him the comfort and encouragement of the gospel. He also took care of the cost of the lad's nursing, and, when the boy died, Calvin paid for the expenses of the burial (Staufer 1971:84-85)."

church, like all human institutions, is full of fallible and selfish people, people like me... my worry with christians who leave it behind, or regularly 'hop' to another place, don't seem to find their christian life enhanced, or their life deepened...

i'm sure there are times when leaving a church is a healthy move... my initial comment was a reaction to the 'consumerist' attitude that so many 21st century christians seem to have to the redeemed but fallen community that Jesus identifies himself with

all the best

brett
Hi Brett, It was nice of you
Posted by  Gwennie on Sun, 28/01/2007 - 6:45pm.
Hi Brett,
It was nice of you to post a reply.

I read the article you mentioned and have to admit that it revealed a side to Calvin that I had no idea existed - so much for a well-rounded theological education! :-)

If I'm very honest, I still don't feel like running off to reread the Institutes but maybe one day...

I have come to realise that the Church is full of fallible, selfish people, including myself, and that is the problem -I've rarely met a Calvin-like pastor; certainly never had one as a leader, but have had a lifetime of the opposite. It is hard not to become cynical.

I also agree that going it alone, in a spiritual sense, does not enhance one's Christian life or experience but have been in a place, for some time, where I'd rather have a coffee with a non-Christian pal on a Sunday morning than sit thro yet another sermon.

Which comes back to the benefits of community -christian or not, in reality- spending time with people who like you is a far bigger draw than exposing yourself to a situation where one is always being "challenged" to be better, or more committed, or more whatever to serve the agenda & goals of the person doing the "challenging" from a pulpit in a church. Or being bored back to sleep & wishing you were back in bed or having that coffee in a cafe round the corner!

Jesus mixed with the outcasts & sinners too, as well as identifying himself with the fallen but redeemed community of believers - I guess I've become more comfortable with the outcasts & sinners (cos I know I'm one) because at least they're honest. They don't pretend to be something they're not.

But, ideally, I would love to be part of a community where the redeemed & not-yet-redeemed both felt comfortable & loved & accepted. Which is why I can't quite give up on the notion of "church" & why I'm trying, however tentatively, to dip my toe back into a Christian community locally.

Anyway, it's good to have a forum in which we can engage honestly. :-)

Best, Gwen
Two communities
Posted by  brett jordan on Mon, 29/01/2007 - 9:34am.
Hi Gwen

glad you've seen a 'new side' of Calvin, like many pivotal Christians (Paul anyone?), I think he gets unnecessarily caricatured

and all the best with your continued journey

brett

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click 'Save settings' to activate your changes.

With love (and extra resources, group-work ideas and links...)
from
www.licc.org.uk/culture.